WASHINGTON -- Two weeks ago, the Pentagon promised to make as many as 2,000 military ventilators available as the federal government strains to contend with the coronavirus pandemic. As of Wednesday, less than half had been allocated, despite a desperate need across the country.
At FEMA, the agency tasked with coordinating the federal response to the coronavirus outbreak, about 9,000 additional ventilators are also on hold as officials seek to determine where they are needed most urgently. Officials have warned states not to expect any shipments until they are within 72 hours of a crisis.
The combination of scarce supply and high need has sent many states onto the open market, where they are bidding for ventilators from private manufacturers. Their competition in that bidding process: both the federal government and other states.
“It's like being on eBay with 50 other states bidding on a ventilator," said New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, whose state is the epicenter of the pandemic in the United States. He urged FEMA to step in and act as a single purchaser of the vital machines.
The slow deployment of ventilators underscores the ways in which the sprawling federal bureaucracy has fallen short in the nation’s response to the crisis. Demand for medical equipment far outpaces the current supply, and the stockpiles that do exist aren’t enough for the hardest hit areas. That undercuts the air of confidence projected by President Donald Trump at his daily briefings.
Cuomo, whose state has had more than 92,000 cases of COVID-19, warned Thursday that New York has only 2,200 ventilators in its own stockpile after shipping out 600 to New York City, Westchester and Long Island. He would run out in six days at this rate.
FEMA has sent 4,400 ventilators to New York, where officials have said they will likely need 20,000 to 40,000 during the crisis.
“I don't think federal government is in a position to provide ventilators to the extent the nation may need them,” he said.
It’s not just ventilators. FEMA has been able to fill only a fraction of the requests for protective equipment and medical supplies requested by the five Mid-Atlantic states and the District of Columbia, according to documents released by Rep. Carolyn B. Maloney, a New York Democrat who is chairwoman of the House Committee on Oversight and Reform.
The shortfalls include less than 10 percent of the requested number of N95 protective masks and none of 15,000 body bags requested.
But ventilators have emerged as one of the most crucial medical tools in treating those suffering from the virus. The machines pump air to a person’s lungs through a tube inserted in the windpipe and can be lifesaving for severely ill patients.
The government had 9,961 ventilators as of Thursday, including 9,054 in the stockpile and 907 from the Department of Defense, according to FEMA.
In Louisiana, where coronavirus cases are skyrocketing, Gov. John Bell Edwards has requested 14,000 ventilators from the federal government and private companies. To date, the state has received just 442, including 150 that arrived Wednesday from the national stockpile.
“The number of new patients needing ventilators under the modeling we’re seeing, the 150 will only get us about a day or so, maybe two if we get really lucky before we’ve exceeded that capacity again,” said Edwards, who has been personally making calls to vendors to try to secure machines for his state.
“It’s not a model of efficiency,” Edwards said.
FEMA is asking states to answer a series of data-heavy questions to determine where the most urgent needs exist. Among the questions: how many usable ventilators, intensive care beds and machines that can be converted into ventilators are available within the state? How many anesthesia machines can be converted into ventilators in the state, and has that happened yet?
FEMA spokeswoman Lizzie Litzow said states should not expect any shipments until they are within 72 hours of a crisis situation.
Several states have already hit that point. The federal government has deployed 2,400 ventilators to New York City, and an additional 2,000 for the rest of the state. FEMA said Wednesday that it was sending machines from the national stockpile to Michigan, New Jersey, Illinois, Connecticut and Louisiana within 24 hours.
Still, the numbers deployed to some of the states pale in comparison to what officials there say they need. For example, Michigan, which reported nearly 10,000 cases as of Wednesday, says it will need between 5,000-10,000 machines. It received 400 ventilators from FEMA on Tuesday.
Connecticut Governor Ned Lamont said in interviews Wednesday that his state has nearly 1,000 ventilators and requested an additional 1,500 ventilators from the national stockpile. It received 50.
The U.S. Conference of Mayors, which represents 213 cities, said a recent survey by its members found 85% do not have an adequate supply of ventilators for use by health facilities in their city or area.
Lawmakers have called repeatedly on the federal government to publicly account for how it is distributing ventilators and personal protective equipment, or PPE, but say they haven’t received answers. Members of the House Homeland Security Committee wrote to the nation’s governors Wednesday asking them to provide the information.
“The Committee is deeply concerned by numerous media reports describing how the growing shortage of PPE and other essential medical equipment is affecting our nation’s capacity to safely test and care for individuals with COVID-19 and leaving medical professionals at substantial and unnecessary risk of acquiring and transmitting the disease,” Rep. Bennie Thompson, a Mississippi Democrat, wrote in the letter.
The Pentagon’s announcement two weeks ago that it had 2,000 ventilators available appeared to be a rare bit of good news. But much of that stockpile is already earmarked for a pair of hospital ships and military field hospitals being deployed to take some of the patient load off other facilities.
About 900 Pentagon ventilators are sitting idle, waiting for FEMA to ask for access.
FEMA officials say the Pentagon equipment requires additional training beyond what is typically required for hospital-grade equipment.
Rather than begin that training now to speed the deployment of the ventilators, the agency says it is focusing on allocating approximately 9,400 more conventional ventilators already in its stockpiles. FEMA said in a statement that those ventilators “are the types of ventilators commonly used by U.S. hospitals and are better suited for immediate use.” It remains unclear how federal officials plan to address the issue of training civilians in local hospitals.
Trump has defended his administration’s deployment of ventilators and said the federal government is doing all it can to add to its stockpiles. He has taken steps to compel General Motors to make more of the machines, though the company was already moving in that direction before the president’s order. He issued an order Thursday under the Defense Production Act aimed at ensuring manufacturers have the supplies to make the machines.
GM said in a joint statement with Ventec on Friday that they expect to deliver the first ventilators next month and will initially produce more than 10,000 per month, with the capability to expand if needed.
Ford, in collaboration with GE Healthcare, said Tuesday that it expects to produce 50,000 of the ventilators within the next 100 days, with the ability to produce 30,000 a month if needed.
———
Associated Press writers Melinda Deslatte in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, David Eggert in Lansing, Michigan, Mike Catalini in Trenton, New Jersey, and Marina Villeneuve in New York contributed to this report.
